Why You’re Losing Sales You Should Be Winning: 5 Ways to Make Every Conversation Count

I’d been feeling completely off recently. I couldn’t quite put my finger on it, but something just wasn’t clicking. My offers didn’t feel right, my motivation was low and I was second-guessing everything. It hadn’t helped that I hadn’t exercised in a week, which really does affect my mindset, and the house was a mess. I felt stuck in my own head, going round in circles. Eventually, I did the two things I’d been putting off: I went to the gym and I cleaned the house. The change in how I felt was instant. It was like someone switched the lights back on. Suddenly, everything made sense. I knew exactly what needed to shift in my business and how to do it.

That moment reminded me how powerful clarity is, and how easily we lose it. It’s the same thing that happens in sales conversations every day. When you’re not fully aligned with your buyer, something just feels off. You can have a great chat, the right offer and all the right intentions, but if you and your buyer aren’t on the same wavelength, it falls flat. What should have been a yes becomes a polite “let me think about it.”

You’re not losing sales because your offer isn’t good enough or your price is too high. You’re losing them because you’re out of sync with how your buyers make decisions. When you understand what’s really happening inside their head, everything changes. You stop guessing, stop over-explaining and start connecting, and that’s the key to knowing how to close more sales without pressure or awkwardness.

Why people don’t buy from you (even when they should)

Let’s face it, the people you’re talking to aren’t just buying a service; they’re buying certainty. They’re asking themselves silently: do I trust this person, do they get me, and will this make my life easier, better or safer? If the answer isn’t a confident yes in their gut, they’ll stall, ghost or politely disappear. That’s not rejection, that’s self-protection.

It’s rarely about your price or your offer. Most of the time, it’s about how the conversation makes them feel. If something feels off, uncertain or rushed, they’ll step back. Buyers need to feel secure before they commit, and that security comes from how you show up, not how hard you sell.

People buy when they feel seen, not when they feel sold to

We’ve all had conversations where someone talks at us instead of to us. It’s rarely intentional, but it happens when you’re so focused on proving your value that you forget to create space for theirs. Buyers want to feel recognised, not rushed. When a potential client feels like you understand their world, their frustrations, hesitations and hopes, their brain literally relaxes. It releases oxytocin, the trust hormone, the same chemical that builds connection in every human relationship.

Instead of convincing, start mirroring. Ask open questions that let them feel heard, like “What’s getting in the way of this right now?” or “What’s most important for you to fix first?” Those kinds of questions show empathy, not agenda. They build trust without needing to sell.

In my blog Selling Without Feeling Salesy, I talk about how focusing on connection instead of performance changes everything. When you stop trying to prove and start trying to understand, people naturally lean in.

Buyers need clarity more than they need convincing

When someone says, “I just need to think about it,” what they really mean is, “I’m not sure yet.” Most people don’t like uncertainty. If your message feels vague, rushed or unclear, their brain pulls the handbrake. They won’t take the risk, not because they don’t want what you offer, but because they don’t yet believe it’s safe to say yes.

Buyers crave clarity. They want to know what happens next, what to expect and how you’ll support them through it. When you clearly explain the journey, you remove the risk of misunderstanding. The clearer you make it, the easier it becomes for them to commit.

Research from HubSpot shows that buyers are more likely to say yes when they can visualise the process clearly. Clarity builds confidence, and confidence creates conversion.

Logic gets attention, but emotion drives action

You can’t out-logic a buyer into action. That’s why lines like “we’re experts,” “we have 20 years’ experience” or “we offer great service” don’t work. People may agree with you logically, but logic doesn’t drive decisions, emotion does.

Behavioural psychologist Daniel Kahneman explains this perfectly in his book Thinking, Fast and Slow. He says the brain runs on two systems: one fast, emotional and instinctive, the other slow, logical and analytical. The fast, emotional system makes the decision, and the slow, logical one justifies it afterwards.

If you want people to buy, you have to reach the emotional side first. Tell stories, paint pictures, and describe what life looks like when their problem is solved. Say, “Imagine finishing the week knowing everything’s running smoothly and you can actually switch off,” instead of, “We provide operational consultancy.” Emotion connects; logic justifies.

Too much information creates confusion

One of the biggest reasons buyers don’t move forward is because they’re overwhelmed. When they’re flooded with options, packages or explanations, they freeze. It’s not that they don’t want what you’re offering; they simply can’t make sense of it.

Buyers trust simplicity because it makes decisions feel easier. If your offer feels complicated, it feels risky. The simpler your message, the safer it feels to say yes.

So simplify what you say. Instead of “We have six different options depending on your goals,” try, “There are two ways we can work together, one’s hands-on, one’s strategic. Which sounds right for you?” You’ve just made the decision easy, and that’s what people want.

Buyers don’t follow up because they didn’t feel emotionally invested

You know that great conversation where everything clicks, but when you follow up, there’s no response? It’s not that they’ve lost interest, it’s that the conversation didn’t anchor emotionally. If they didn’t connect to the outcome at a deeper level, it won’t stay front of mind.

Before ending a call, bring the conversation back to emotion. Ask, “If we could fix this, what difference would it make for you right now?” That question makes them articulate the benefit in their own words. Once they do, it sticks. They’ve essentially sold themselves on the value.

In my blog Hate Selling? Here’s How to Finally Feel Confident Asking for the Sale, I talk about how confidence and empathy go hand in hand. When people feel emotionally connected, you don’t need to chase. They follow through because they want to, not because you’ve reminded them.

Bringing it back to alignment

That week when I was out of alignment reminded me that the problem isn’t always what we’re doing; it’s how we’re showing up. Sales is exactly the same. When your energy, message and process align with how your buyers think, conversations feel effortless. Selling stops feeling like convincing and starts feeling like helping. You’re not forcing a decision; you’re guiding one.

Final thought

People buy from people they trust, and trust is built through clarity, empathy and understanding. The more you focus on why people don’t buy from you, the easier it becomes to learn how to close more sales. If you’re ready to find out where your sales conversations might be missing the mark, take your Business Performance Health Check. It’s a quick quiz that helps you identify what’s out of sync in your business and shows you where small shifts can make a big difference in your results.

​